Updated Nov 22, 2026· 14 min read

Key takeaways

  • Find the best compost bins for kitchen scraps and garden waste, from countertop caddies to large outdoor tumblers and stationary bins for every yard size.

Kitchen scraps and garden waste do not have to go in the trash. A good compost bin turns peelings, coffee grounds, leaves, and grass clippings into material that feeds garden beds, and the right bin depends on how much waste a household makes, how much space is available, and whether the work happens at the kitchen counter or out in the yard. Countertop caddies handle daily scraps, while outdoor tumblers and stationary bins take the larger loads that come from a garden.

Our top pick: simplehuman Compost Caddy. Runner-up: OGGI Countertop Compost Bin.

This guide covers five bins that span that whole range, from a four-liter caddy that docks beside a trash can to an eighty-gallon tumbler built for a large yard. Each pick below is described from its published listing details, including capacity, material, and the way it opens, turns, or empties.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Table of Contents

Quick Answer

For a small kitchen, the simplehuman Compost Caddy is the easiest daily option because it docks beside a trash can and lifts off for countertop use. For a medium garden, the MaxWorks 80699 dual-chamber tumbler keeps one batch curing while the other fills. For the largest loads, the Lifetime 60058 holds eighty gallons in a single drum.

simplehuman Compost Caddy

The simplehuman Compost Caddy is the pick for a household that wants composting to fit into normal kitchen work without taking over the counter. It holds four liters, about one gallon, so it suits daily peelings, coffee grounds, and eggshells rather than a full garden cleanup. The caddy is made from plastic and stainless steel, with a white finish, and it measures 9.6 inches long by 5.5 inches wide by 8.7 inches high.

What sets this caddy apart is the magnetic dock. The caddy attaches to a magnetic dock that hangs at the side of a simplehuman rectangular or slim liner rim trash can, so scraps can be scraped straight from a cutting board into the caddy. When more room is needed at the counter, the caddy detaches from the dock and works as a standalone countertop bin.

Odor control here works differently from bins that use a charcoal filter. This caddy has no charcoal filter in its lid. Instead, it uses a soft-seal lid that allows food scraps to breathe, which the listing describes as odor-minimizing, keeping odor under control and keeping pests such as fruit flies away. A filter needs replacing on a schedule, while a breathable lid needs no replacement part. The trade-off is that the caddy works best when it is emptied often, ideally every day or two.

The plastic inner bucket is removable, so it can be lifted out, tipped into an outdoor composter or a collection bin, and rinsed. A thirty-pack of Code Z custom fit compostable liners is included, and the liners are sized to fit the caddy without overhang. Because the liners are compostable, they can go out with the food scraps and decompose fully.

Specs

    • Capacity: 4 liters (1.06 gallons)
    • Material: Plastic, stainless steel
    • Color: White
    • Dimensions: 9.6 x 5.5 x 8.7 inches
    • Item weight: 1.3 kilograms
    • Special feature: Detachable, magnetic docking
    • Lid: Soft-seal lid, no charcoal filter
    • Inner bucket: Removable plastic bucket
    • Liners included: 30-pack of Code Z custom fit compostable liners

    OGGI Countertop Compost Bin

    The OGGI Countertop Compost Bin is a classic stainless steel pail for a kitchen that wants a simple, sturdy container with a charcoal filter in the lid. It holds one gallon, listed as 3.8 liters, and its cylindrical body measures 7.25 inches long by 7.25 inches wide by 11.75 inches high. At four pounds, it sits firmly on a counter without sliding when scraps are scraped in, and the stainless steel body resists stains and odors from wet scraps better than bare plastic.

    The charcoal filter is the heart of this bin. A charcoal filter fits inside the lid, and it is designed to absorb odors and reduce smell in the kitchen, keeping the bin odor-free until waste is transferred outside. The listing states that charcoal filters are included so composting can start right away. Filters wear out, so replacements are a running cost.

    Use of the bin is deliberately plain. There is no dock, no mounting bracket, and no liner system built into the listing. Scraps go in through the lid, the lid closes, and the pail is carried outside when full. The stainless steel body wipes clean, and the cylindrical shape has no corners where scraps can lodge, which helps with rinsing. A liner can be used inside if preferred, though none is included, so buyers who want liners should add them separately.

    Capacity is the main decision point. One gallon holds a day or two of scraps for a small household, and less than a day when a large meal is being prepared. That makes the OGGI a good match for one or two people, or for a kitchen where a larger bin would crowd the counter. Compared with the simplehuman caddy above, the OGGI trades the magnetic dock and included liners for a charcoal filter and a heavier stainless steel body, so the choice comes down to filter versus dock.

    Specs

      • Capacity: 1 gallon (3.8 liters)
      • Material: Stainless steel
      • Color: Stainless steel
      • Dimensions: 7.25 x 7.25 x 11.75 inches
      • Item weight: 4 pounds
      • Shape: Cylindrical
      • Lid: Charcoal filter fitted inside the lid
      • Model number: 7320

      MaxWorks 80699 Compost Bin Tumbler

      The MaxWorks 80699 is the pick for a medium garden that needs continuous composting without waiting for one batch to finish before starting another. It is a dual-chamber tumbling composter with a total capacity of forty-two gallons, made up of two independent twenty-one-gallon chambers. One chamber can cure while the other is filled, which keeps a steady supply of compost moving through the garden season.

      Construction is a mix of UV-resistant polypropylene for the drum and a powder-coated alloy steel frame underneath. The drum is octagonal, which gives it flat panels that catch and turn material as the drum rotates, and the frame holds the drum off the ground at a height that makes loading easier than bending to a ground-level pile. The assembled unit measures 28.5 inches long by 26 inches wide by 36.8 inches high, and it weighs 25.8 pounds empty.

      Airflow and access work together. Integrated aeration vents let air into the drum, and sliding doors give access to each chamber for loading and for removing finished compost. The listing states that the rotating drum mixes oxygen into organic material, while the vents and sliding doors regulate airflow and moisture. Turning is part of the routine: the listing suggests five to six turns every few days, and states that compost can be ready in as little as two to four weeks depending on climate and material composition.

      The dual-chamber design changes how a household plans its composting. Kitchen scraps go into the active chamber until it is full, then that chamber is left to cure while fresh material goes into the second chamber. When the first chamber is emptied, the roles swap. That cycle avoids adding fresh scraps to a nearly finished batch and resetting the clock. The trade-off is that each chamber holds only twenty-one gallons, so a large garden cleanup will fill a chamber quickly.

      Specs

        • Capacity: 42 gallons total (two 21-gallon chambers)
        • Material: UV-resistant polypropylene drum, powder-coated alloy steel frame
        • Color: Black
        • Dimensions: 28.5 x 26 x 36.8 inches
        • Item weight: 25.8 pounds
        • Shape: Octagonal drum
        • Chambers: Dual chamber, two sliding doors
        • Aeration: Integrated aeration vents
        • Model number: 80699

        Lifetime 60058 Compost Tumbler

        The Lifetime 60058 is the largest tumbler in this guide, and it is the pick for a large yard with heavy garden waste. It holds eighty gallons, listed as 302.8 liters, in a single chamber, which is nearly double the total capacity of the dual-chamber tumbler above. That volume suits a household with a large garden, frequent lawn mowing, autumn leaf fall, and regular kitchen scraps. The trade-off is that the drum is a single chamber, so fresh material added mid-batch joins material that is already partway through composting.

        The drum is built from UV-protected high-density polyethylene panels with a double-wall design. The listing states that the dark, double-wall panels absorb and retain heat, which helps decomposition, and that the panels are durable and UV-protected for outdoor use. The base is galvanized steel, which resists corrosion in wet garden conditions. Inside the drum, an internal aeration bar mixes compost and provides airflow as the drum turns. A spring-loaded pin locks rotation during filling.

        Loading and unloading are shaped by the extra-large removable lid. The lid comes off completely, which gives a wide opening for adding bulky leaves, grass clippings, and prunings, and for scooping out finished compost. That wide opening is a real advantage over a tumbler with a small sliding door. The assembled unit measures 35.5 inches long by 40 inches wide by 43 inches high in the listing, and it weighs 19,100 grams, which is about 42.1 pounds empty. That size needs a dedicated patch of yard.

        The single-chamber design needs a plan. A household that fills the drum steadily through spring and summer can let the batch finish in autumn, then start a fresh batch. A household that wants finished compost all season long may prefer a dual-chamber model. A How to Compost DVD is included in the box.

        Specs

          • Capacity: 80 gallons (302.8 liters)
          • Material: UV-protected high-density polyethylene panels, galvanized steel base
          • Color: Black
          • Dimensions: 35.5 x 40 x 43 inches
          • Item weight: 19,100 grams (about 42.1 pounds)
          • Chambers: Single chamber
          • Lid: Extra-large removable lid
          • Aeration: Internal aeration bar
          • Rotation lock: Spring-loaded pin
          • Model number: 60058

          Redmon Outdoor Compost Bin

          The Redmon Outdoor Compost Bin is the stationary pick in this guide, and it suits a gardener who wants a simple bin that stays in one place and never needs turning. It holds sixty-five gallons, and it is made from plastic constructed using eighty percent post-consumer recycled materials. That recycled content is a real distinction: most bins in this guide use new plastic or steel, while this bin is built largely from material that has already been used once. The bin is black, trapezoid in shape, and it weighs fifteen pounds.

          Access is the strength of this design. The bin has a snap-off lifting lid on top for adding fresh material, and four access doors, one on each side, for reaching finished compost at the bottom. Fresh scraps go in at the top while finished compost comes out through a lower door, without tipping the bin over or digging down through fresh material. Multiple vent holes allow for proper aeration and release of gases. Because the bin does not rotate, aeration depends on those vent holes and on occasional turning of the contents by hand.

          The assembled bin measures twenty-six inches long by twenty-six inches wide by 30.75 inches high, according to the maker, and it stands on the ground rather than on a raised frame. That ground contact matters: worms and microbes can enter from the soil below, and moisture can drain naturally. It also means the bin should sit on level soil, away from windows and doors, since a stationary pile can attract insects even when the lid is closed. A composting guide is included, and assembly is described as easy, with no tools required for setup.

          The one-year limited warranty is the shortest warranty in this guide, and it is worth noting for a bin that lives outside year-round. The plastic is described as rugged and built to stand up to weather and outdoor elements, but a stationary bin still faces sun, rain, and frost, and the lid and doors are the parts most likely to wear. With no frame, drum, or sliding doors, there are fewer moving parts to fail, which offsets the shorter warranty in practice.

          Specs

            • Capacity: 65 gallons
            • Material: Plastic, 80 percent post-consumer recycled materials
            • Color: Black
            • Dimensions: 26 x 26 x 30.75 inches
            • Item weight: 15 pounds
            • Shape: Trapezoid
            • Lid: Snap-off lifting lid
            • Access: 4 access doors, one on each side
            • Aeration: Multiple vent holes
            • Warranty: 1 year limited

            How to Choose

            Start with volume, because capacity decides whether a bin helps or frustrates. A countertop caddy holds about a gallon, which suits daily scraps for one or two people. A forty-two-gallon tumbler suits a medium garden with steady trimmings. A sixty-five-gallon stationary bin suits a garden with a permanent composting corner. An eighty-gallon tumbler suits a large yard with heavy seasonal waste. Buying too small means constant emptying, while buying too large means a half-empty drum that never heats up properly.

            Next, decide between a caddy, a tumbler, and a stationary bin, because each type asks for a different routine. A caddy is a daily habit: fill it, carry it out, rinse it. A tumbler asks for regular turning, several turns every few days, and rewards that work with faster composting. A stationary bin asks for patience and occasional stirring by hand. Households that will not turn a drum should not buy a tumbler, because an unturned tumbler is just an expensive stationary bin.

            Then look at the details that affect daily use. Check the lid or door: a charcoal filter helps with odor in a kitchen pail, a breathable lid avoids replacement filters, a sliding door gives easy access to a tumbler chamber, and a lift-off lid gives the widest opening for bulky leaves. Check the material and the assembled dimensions, and measure the spot where the bin will sit, including room for a wheelbarrow beside an outdoor bin. Finally, think about what goes into the bin: kitchen scraps, coffee grounds, eggshells, leaves, grass clippings, and shredded paper all compost well when mixed in balance, while meat, dairy, and diseased plants do not belong in a home bin.

            Who Should Skip It

            A compost bin is not the right purchase for every household. A household with no garden, no houseplants, and no collection service for food scraps will struggle to use finished compost, and the bin will sit full while scraps keep going to the trash. In that case, a collection service or a community compost drop-off makes more sense, because the finished material needs somewhere to go.

            Space is the next reason to skip. A tumbler needs a level patch of yard with room to turn and room for a wheelbarrow, and a stationary bin needs a permanent corner on level ground. A countertop caddy alone will not solve the problem, because the caddy still needs an outdoor bin or a collection point to empty into. Households in apartments without a yard or a collection service should check local composting options before buying.

            Effort is the third reason. Composting asks for a routine: emptying a caddy every day or two, turning a tumbler several times a week, or stirring a stationary pile now and then. A household that travels often will end up with a bin full of old scraps rather than a bin full of compost. Renters should also check whether a landlord or a homeowners association restricts outdoor bins, because a bin that must be removed after purchase is a wasted purchase.

            Frequently Asked Questions

            What size compost bin do I need?

            Size depends on how much waste the household makes and how much garden space needs feeding. A one-gallon countertop caddy suits daily kitchen scraps for one or two people. A forty-two-gallon tumbler suits a medium garden with steady trimmings. A sixty-five-gallon stationary bin suits a garden with a permanent composting corner, and an eighty-gallon tumbler suits a large yard with heavy seasonal waste.

            How often should I empty a countertop compost caddy?

            Empty a caddy every day or two, before scraps start to smell or attract fruit flies. A caddy holds about a gallon, so it fills quickly in a household that cooks at home, and a breathable lid or a charcoal filter only helps while the load is fresh. Rinse the inner bucket after emptying, and replace the liner if one is used.

            Do I need to turn a compost tumbler?

            Yes, turning is the work that makes a tumbler faster than a stationary pile. Turning mixes oxygen into the material, breaks up clumps, and keeps the pile from compacting into a wet mass. The listing for the dual-chamber tumbler in this guide suggests five to six turns every few days. A tumbler that is never turned will still compost, but it will take much longer.

            Can I put meat and dairy in a home compost bin?

            No, meat and dairy do not belong in a home compost bin. They attract pests, produce strong odor as they break down, and can carry organisms that a home pile does not get hot enough to destroy. The same applies to diseased plants, which can carry problems into the garden when the finished compost is spread. Stick to vegetable scraps, fruit peelings, coffee grounds, eggshells, leaves, grass clippings, and shredded paper, and keep the mix balanced between wet green material and dry brown material.

            Conclusion

            The best compost bin is the one that matches the waste a household makes and the routine it will keep. A small kitchen does well with the simplehuman Compost Caddy or the OGGI Countertop Compost Bin, one with a magnetic dock and included liners, the other with a charcoal filter and a sturdy stainless steel body. A medium garden does well with the MaxWorks 80699 dual-chamber tumbler, which keeps one batch curing while the other fills. A large yard does well with the Lifetime 60058 eighty-gallon tumbler. A garden with a permanent corner does well with the Redmon Outdoor Compost Bin, a stationary bin that takes material in at the top and gives finished compost out through lower doors.

            Start with the smallest bin that fits the daily routine, and let the outdoor bin match the garden. Empty the caddy often, turn the tumbler on schedule, and give a stationary pile time to finish. Done that way, kitchen scraps and garden waste become useful material for the garden instead of waste in the trash.

            Product and ASIN Reference

            Product ASIN
            simplehuman Compost Caddy B0BWL21RD5
            OGGI Countertop Compost Bin B001RNEW4Y
            MaxWorks 80699 Compost Bin Tumbler B07177P4FH
            Lifetime 60058 Compost Tumbler B0030GG2FS
            Redmon Outdoor Compost Bin B003HOR8BK
            A
            affadmin
            We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
            Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.
            Best Compost Bins for Kitchen and Garden Waste…Check price on Amazon

            More from Amazon

            Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.

            Amazon Prime

            Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

            Start a Prime free trial
            Amazon Music Unlimited

            Ad-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.

            Try Music Unlimited free
            Prime for Young Adults

            A Prime membership for ages 18-24 with a trial period. Eligibility is set by Amazon.

            See Prime for Young Adults
            Audible

            Audiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

            Try Audible free

            As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.